Doubled Plots: Romance and History
Edited by Susan Strehle
Edited by Mary Paniccia Carden
9781604732511 Paper $25.00D
An examination of how two diverse genres parallel and reflect each other
In art, myth, and popular culture, romance is connected with the realm of emotions, private thought, and sentimentality. History, its counterpart, is the seemingly objective compendium of public fact. In theory, the two genres are diametrically opposed, offering widely divergent views of human experience.
In this collection of essays, however, the writers challenge these basic assumptions and consider the two as parallel and as reflections of each other. Looking closely at specific narratives, they argue that romance and history share expectations and purposes and create the metaphors that can either hold cultures and institutions together or drive them apart. The writers explore the internal contradictions of both genres, as seen in works in which the elements of both romance and history are present. The theme that flows throughout this collection is that romance literature and art frequently engage with or comment on actual historical events or histories.
Included among the contributions are discussions of romance and race in James Fenimore Cooper's The Last of the Mohicans, the Rudolph Valentino film classic The Sheik, the series of English "Regency Romance" novels, the constructs of love and history in two of Alice McDermott's novels, and a feminist reading of African American women's historical romances.
Moreover, the essays approach romance and history from a variety of critical and political perspectives and examine a wide selection of romances from the 1800s to contemporary times. They look at bestsellers and literary classics, at texts by and for white audiences, and at works created by writers on the margins of Western culture.
The anthology is a radical approach to romance, a genre often dismissed as diversionary and reactionary. It explores how well this genre serves for critical examinations of history.
Susan Strehle, a professor of English at Binghamton University, is the author of Fiction in the Quantum Universe. Her work has been published in Critique, Review of Contemporary Fiction, Contemporary Literature, and Modern Fiction Studies.
Mary Paniccia Carden, an assistant professor of English at Edinboro University of Pennsylvania, has been published in Twentieth-Century Literature, Modern Fiction Studies, Prose Studies, and the Journal of Contemporary Thought.